The Healthcare Diff Part 2

I received some good comments on my post The Healthcare Diff including some on Hacker News. One reader pointed to this excellent article in The New Yorker by Atul Gawande. Gawande says the Senate healthcare bill is chock-full of experiments, it’s just they are called pilot programs. The article includes an extended analogy between healthcare today and the state of agriculture in the early 20th century. He asserts the transition to a modern efficient system of food production was largely due to government sponsored pilot programs.

This is very encouraging.

One reason information about the healthcare bill’s contents is not widely known is “the process story”.

NPR reported that the media loves explaining the process by which a bill is making its way through Congress, but they generally minimize discussion of the bills themselves. For example here is the top hit in a search for “healthcare” on Google News for each of the last 14 days:

March 17th: Nuns in US back healthcare bill despite Catholic bishops’ opposition

March 16th: Democrats Gain Momentum for Healthcare vote, but Process Draws GOP Attacks

March 15th: House Democrats Begin Final Push on Healthcare as Pressures Intensify

March 14th: Democrats lack votes to pass healthcare bill, but White House confident

March 13th: Obama delays Asia trip to push healthcare overhaul

March 12th: Middle East peace efforts: lessons from healthcare reform

March 11th: Democrats Edge Nearer Agreement on Final Healthcare Package, but Obstacles Remain

March 10th: Panel on Compromises to Pass Health Care; What’s Next in Afghanistan?

March 9th: Abortion could stymie healthcare reform legislation

March 8th: Obama adds fire to healthcare debate

March 7th: Anthem a boon to Obama’s healthcare efforts

March 6th: Obama: Congress ‘Must Act Now’ On Health Care Bill

March 5th: Obama’s Health Care Push: The Race is On

March 4th: Pressure mounts for/against healthcare bill

It’s clear that a casual observation of the daily news will not teach you much about the bill itself, only about its status. As the NPR reporter quipped “news is what’s new”. A good reason to continue to support long-form journalism like The New Yorker!

Two other good links from the comments

  • Impressive RAND study conducted from 1971 and 1982 about “cost sharing” and health care effectiveness
  • Paul Fromer talk on “Charter Cities”, a radical call for experimental governments.